NYC Wins Appeal to Enforce Adult Store Zoning Law

By: Andy Powell, Senior Editor | JRL CHARTS — Adult Industry News

NEW YORK, NY — (July 8, 2025) — In a major legal blow to the adult retail sector, the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld New York City’s aggressive zoning laws targeting adult entertainment businesses. The ruling affirms that municipalities can restrict the location of adult stores and clubs, even when such businesses are protected by the First Amendment¹.

Related Coverage on JRL CHARTS:

Federal Court: Cities Can Regulate Adult Content Through Zoning

The appeals court sided with the city in a lawsuit brought by 14 strip clubs and adult bookstores, who claimed the zoning regulations were unconstitutional. The court rejected those arguments, finding that the city had “a proper justification” for distinguishing adult establishments and mandating relocation if necessary.

“This is a significant decision for municipalities looking to curb adult business presence in dense urban zones,” said a city planning official familiar with the ruling.

The case centered on amendments made in 2001 to New York’s original 1995 zoning laws. These rules were aimed at pushing adult businesses out of high-profile areas like Midtown Manhattan.

What the Zoning Law Requires

The city’s zoning regulations impose strict criteria on adult businesses:

Definition: Any commercial venue where a “substantial portion” of its operations involve adult material or entertainment
Distance Requirements: Must be at least 500 feet from schools, places of worship, daycares, residential areas, or other adult businesses
Zoning Districts: Permitted only in select industrial or commercial zones
Density & Size Caps: Limits on square footage and number of adult establishments per block
Amortization: Non-compliant stores have 1 year to move, close, or seek an extension

City Cites “Secondary Effects” to Justify Restrictions

The court agreed with the city’s argument that adult businesses contribute to negative secondary effects like increased crime, lower property values, and quality-of-life disruptions². These findings, drawn from impact studies, have long been used as a legal basis for zoning enforcement nationwide.

The ruling confirms a 2024 lower court decision and further cements New York City’s right to regulate adult retail locations, potentially opening the door for similar crackdowns in other major cities.

Footnotes

The First Amendment protects adult expression, but courts have repeatedly ruled that municipalities may regulate adult businesses through zoning as long as the intent is not censorship but mitigating negative secondary effects.
“Secondary effects” doctrine stems from city-funded studies linking adult businesses to higher rates of crime, reduced property values, and public nuisance concerns — a long-standing legal justification used in zoning battles nationwide.

Stay with JRL CHARTS Adult Industry News for breaking legal rulings that impact adult retailers, distributors, and store operators across the U.S.